CA Family Court Custody Mediation vs. Private Mediation: Which Should I Choose?

When a Request for Order (RFO) for child custody or visitation is filed with Family Court the parties are required to attend mediation or child custody recommending counseling (CCRC), depending on the jurisdiction you are in. Both mediation and CCRC are led by an experienced counselor or psychotherapist with a master’s degree related to marriage and family interpersonal relationships. The goal of mediation is to help you and your spouse come to agreements regarding your children. Assuming you and your spouse are in agreement, you can choose to opt out of working with a family court mediator and instead retain a private mediator. Both of you will attend mediation together unless a restraining order is in place (or violence is alleged), in which case you will meet separately with the mediator.

Regardless of which type of mediation is selected, the goal is for the two of you to agree on as many issues as possible. The focus is on the children’s safety, welfare and best interests. Issues include physical and legal custody, timeshare, schools children should attend, holiday schedules, medical needs, special needs, activities for the children and other topics that involve the children. You will each have the opportunity to express your position and/or proposed parenting schedule and the reasoning behind your respective positions. The mediator helps with negotiating, compromising and insight to assist you in coming to as many agreements on the issues concerning the children as possible.

In some counties, the mediator will submit a report to the court that includes a brief summary of both parent’s requests and concerns followed by the mediator’s recommendations. Mediation is sometimes on the day of your court hearing but usually several days or weeks before you have to appear in court. Assuming you and your spouse are unable to come to an agreement regarding your children in mediation or on your own, your case will proceed to court. Both of you will have an opportunity to present your evidence and express your positions to the judge. In many counties, the judge will review the mediator’s recommendations. While these recommendations are not binding on the Court, they can certainly be persuasive.


Family Court Mediation

Family Court Services Mediators (FCS) work for the court. In some counties you are notified by mail of the mediation date, location and time. Other counties require you to call in and schedule your session. In a few counties mediation is held the day of the court hearing.

Things to consider

  • You usually only have one meeting with a court (FCS) mediator.
  • FCS mediation sessions are between 20-60 minutes long. You don’t have a whole lot of time to present your side of the story.

There is no follow up session if something is forgotten, or time runs out to make your position fully known and understood by the mediator. Often there is no time for the mediator to speak with your child(ren).

On same-day mediation, parents get their one time with the mediator and hope the recommendations go their way. The mediator will make recommendations with very little time to gather all of the information needed to make a well informed decision.

Cost

There is no charge to parents for FCS mediation. However, if you have an attorney, you may wind up having to pay them while they wait (they don’t attend with you). Attorneys are paid for all court time, including appearing before, during and after mediation.


Private mediators (often referred to as Private Child Custody Recommending Counselors) do charge for their services and the total cost depends on the number of sessions necessary, whether or not the kid(s) will be met with and if there is additional information (such as an IEP report or pleadings) that you or your spouse want your mediator to read. Mediators also charge for their time to write their report and recommendations. However, it’s a good idea to remember that mediators are generally much cheaper than lawyers. Additionally, their goal is to help facilitate a settlement. Unlike FCS mediation, you have plenty of time to share your concerns, work on co-parenting skills and try to come to an agreement. If you decide to go the private mediator route, check your county to see if they have a local form to appoint a private mediator or use our template.

Mediation can be avoided all together if you and your spouse agree on all issues pertaining to their children. Even if the agreement is temporary, it’s certainly a good start to your divorce. If you do come to an agreement before your court hearing, prepare a Stipulation and Order. Our template is here.

To learn more about child custody mediation, check out a
few of our other resources below:
You can still get a divorce, even with court closures. Here’s how.
+

Pin It on Pinterest