A counterclaim, in the context of divorce, is a legal tool that allows the respondent (the person who received the divorce papers) to assert their own claims against the petitioner (the person who initiated the divorce).
Filing a counterclaim is not just a defensive move; it's also an opportunity for the respondent to tell their side of the story and make their own demands regarding crucial matters such as custody of minor children, spousal support/alimony, and marital property division.
A counterclaim for divorce may be filed after the respondent receives the initial complaint or petition for divorce. It's part of the formal response process to the divorce filing, and it’s usually due within a specific frame of time set by the court.
Filing a counterclaim can be a strategic move in divorce. You might file one in order to represent your interests in court and protect yourself in the divorce process.
Examples of counterclaims
Here are two fictional examples of a divorce counterclaim in action.
Counterclaim regarding child custody
Jane receives divorce papers from her husband, John. In his petition, John has requested full custody of their two children. Jane disagrees with this demand. She believes that joint custody is in the best interest of their kids. So, she files a counterclaim requesting joint legal and physical custody, which would give both parents equal decision-making authority and time with the children.
Counterclaim regarding property division
Mark is served with divorce papers from his wife, Lisa. Lisa's petition demands that she retain their marital home. Mark feels this is unfair, as he made significant financial contributions to the home. In his counterclaim, he requests that the court order the sale of the house and that the couple split the proceeds equitably.
The above examples illustrate how counterclaims can be used to assert your rights to the court system and make your own demands in a potential court case. It's important to remember that these are simplified scenarios, and real-life divorce proceedings can be much more complex.
FAQ about counterclaims
Is evidence required in a counterclaim?
Yes, your counterclaim should be backed up by evidence. This could include financial records, communication logs, or testimonies that support your claims. Having solid evidence can strengthen your case and help you get a more favorable outcome.
What happens after a counterclaim is filed?
Once a counterclaim is filed, it must be served to the petitioner, who then has a chance to respond. The court will consider both the original complaint and the counterclaim when deciding on matters like property division, child custody, and spousal support/alimony. The process may involve negotiation and mediation that lead to a settlement agreement. Or, the divorce case may go to trial.
Do I need a lawyer if I want to file a counterclaim?
While it's not legally required to have a lawyer to file a counterclaim, it's often beneficial. Family law can be complex, and a lawyer can help make sure your rights are protected and guide you through the process.
At Hello Divorce, we offer hourly attorney consultations, which may be of help in a situation like this. Click to read more about our services, or schedule a free 15-minute call with an account coordinator.
Are you covering everything in your Divorce Agreement?
See what most people include in their Agreements with our free download.
